Skip to content



Here’s a sample of reviews and testimonials from our past clients. Read all of our reviews on Zillow or Google.

I can’t say enough good things about Paul. He made our first-time home-buying experience feel easy. It’s amazing how much Paul knows. He practically doubled as a home inspector when we were seeing houses. He’s very honest and upfront with details about the house and gives the right information to make the best decision. He’s incredibly responsive and communicative at all hours. We were able to get a great house in our top neighborhood after a month working with Paul. I could keep going, but you should just choose Paul for your real estate needs. 

Paul was an excellent agent to work with. He was super knowledgeable of the area, knew a ton about the major builders and the quality of the homes they built, and had a very keen eye on identifying flaws that could hurt you down the road. He’s super easy to work and quick to respond, and always going above and beyond to help you find the home that’s right for you. Definitely would use his services again. Highly recommend. –
Eric D.

Paul is an incredibly patient and thorough agent. He truly has the buyer’s best interest in mind. We learned so much while working with him and we started to feel badly for people who weren’t working with him, because he is that good. He has very in-depth knowledge about the Madison area; it is quite amazing actually! He was so patient with us during the six months we were looking for our house and he was there each step of the way. We lost count of how many houses we saw with him but it had to be over 40, and the majority of the time we had our very energetic and inquisitive four and one year old with us for viewings! Last second showings, six showings in a morning marathons, multiple offers, plus we were first time homebuyers so that adds another layer of fun for everyone…he was a champ for us! Thank you, Paul! We would absolutely use Paul in the future. And, we LOVE our new house. It was worth the wait!!

Zillow User

A+ Realtor! Reasons to choose Paul as your Real Estate Agent: Paul is DEPENDABLE. I reached out to Paul after reading some zillow reviews that specifically stated he was great with first time home-buyers. I am a young, single female buying a house on my own and I really needed someone who would help me through the process and truly be on my side. Paul is RESPONSIVE. Paul is SO responsive that you feel like you are his #1 customer. He returns emails usually within minutes. He’s able to meet you for a viewing around your schedule almost every time. Houses go FAST in the Madison area, so you need someone like Paul who’s able to work at that speed! (…) Paul was there every step of the way! I just had to pay the bill! Paul is FUNNY and PERSONABLE. House buying can be stressful! So why not make it fun?! Paul goes ABOVE AND BEYOND! From big gestures at closing, to helping me to move a few boxes at move-in, to even still checking in 3 months after closing, I’m incredibly appreciative for Paul and how he has helped me to find and purchase a home that is far above my expectations!

Erin E.

Paul Anderson helped me search, locate, competitively bid, and successfully purchase my forever home in Madison. Thank you, Paul. Your knowledge of the area, market, and process were impressive to say the least. I’ve never worked with someone so knowledgeable and clearly dedicated to helping me. You listened to all of my concerns, were always patient with me (a nervous nellie), and helped me to understand the market and process. You are the best in the business and have my highest recommendation. Please feel free to use me as a reference if ever needed.

Stacy S.

Paul is phenomenal at his craft. He has a vast knowledge of the Madison/Middleton area. He is laser-focused on meeting the needs of his clients, listening carefully and asking the right questions. He is personable and responsive. I would recommend Paul to anyone looking to buy or sell. 

G. Stone

Paul helped us buy our first home. He held our hands every step of the way. He even gave us advice on how to care and maintain our home. Paul made the process about as smooth and easy as it could possibly be.

H. Domaszek

My family and I were relocating to Madison on a short time-table and knew very little about the town or the market. Paul came highly regarded from a colleague and didn’t disappoint. Paul was wonderful in every regard and we recommend him without reservation. He has a great sense of humor and did a good job dealing with us over an intense week of house searching.

Zillow Buyer

Paul is extremely intelligent when it comes to houses. He isn’t afraid to point out the bad parts of a house to make sure you don’t make a mistake when buying. His focus is on your happiness. I thoroughly enjoyed working with Paul and Highly recommend him to all my friends who are in the market! 

M. Rush

This is our first home, and we are very happy to work with Paul. Paul has all the knowledge about a house, and with detailed pros and cons analysis, we finally find what we need. We will definitely recommend him to our friends!!!

Zillow Buyer

Working with Paul is a pleasure. Paul has unmatched experience, input, and patience. We worked with Paul when purchasing our home several years ago, and worked with him again to sell it. Paul takes the time to explain everything in detail, answer our myriad of questions, walk us through every step  of the way, offer suggestions when we were navigating tricky situations, and ultimately, know what needs to get done and when in order to sell a house. For reference, our house was on the market 1 day and we got over asking for it. Paul is hyper-organized and in every situation, his experience shows. Also, Paul is just fun to work with! 

V. Nelson

Paul helped us purchase several different parcels of vacant land in Iowa County to eventually build a home on. Paul successfully negotiated better than expected prices and also helped us work through due diligence and zoning issues. His knowledge and experience in real estate was readily apparent. He was in constant communication with us and kept us well informed. Even the seller’s realtor expressed how much she enjoyed working with Paul. I would highly recommend Paul to anyone looking to buy or sell a home or land. 

V. Irvin

Madison Buyer Agency  |  Privacy Policy  |  all rights reserved 2020